Consumer Proposal Myths Debunked

Consumer Proposal Myths Debunked

There are many myths about consumer proposals in Ontario. This page explains the truth in simple,
clear language so you can make the right financial decision.

Common Myths About Consumer Proposals

Many people avoid consumer proposals because of myths and misunderstandings.

The truth is that a proposal can reduce your debt by about 70%, protect your assets, and give you one affordable payment. This page breaks down the most common myths so you can understand exactly how a consumer proposal really works.

Myth 1: “I’ll lose my home, car, or RRSPs.”

Consumer-Proposal-Myths

Consumer-Proposal-Myths

This is one of the most common myths, but it is completely inaccurate. A consumer proposal is designed to protect your assets. When you file, you keep your:

  • home (as long as you stay current on your mortgage)
  • vehicle (financed or owned)
  • RRSPs (except for very recent contributions)
  • personal belongings

This protection exists because a proposal is a settlement, not a liquidation. Unlike bankruptcy, a proposal does not require you to surrender anything. For many people, this is the main reason they choose a proposal instead of filing bankruptcy.

Myth 2: “My credit will never recover.”

A consumer proposal does affect your credit, but not permanently. Your score improves as soon as your finances stabilize.

Recovery happens because the proposal:

  • reduces your debt by about 70%
  • freezes all interest
  • lowers your credit utilization
  • gives you consistent monthly payments

Credit scoring models reward stability, and a proposal makes your finances stable again. With simple rebuilding steps like using a secured card, paying bills on time, and keeping balances low, many people see improvements within 6 to 12 months.

Myth 3: “I’ll have to repay everything I owe.”

A consumer proposal is a legally binding debt reduction plan. Most people repay only 30% or less of their debt with no interest over three to five years.

You pay less because the trustee designs the proposal based on:

  • what you can afford
  • what creditors typically accept
  • what creditors would receive in a bankruptcy

Since creditors prefer a proposal over bankruptcy, they often accept significantly reduced amounts. This is how the typical 70% savings is achieved.

Myth 4: “Creditors will never accept my proposal.”

Most consumer proposals are accepted because they offer creditors more money than bankruptcy.

Trustees structure proposals using:

  • industry guidelines
  • creditor voting patterns
  • realistic monthly repayment amounts

This is why the majority of proposals pass on the first vote with little or no changes.

Myth 5: “It’s basically the same as bankruptcy.”

A consumer proposal is very different from bankruptcy.

With a proposal:

  • you keep all your assets
  • your monthly payment is fixed
  • your income does not increase your payment
  • your debt is reduced
  • your credit recovers faster than bankruptcy

Bankruptcy has stricter rules, potential asset loss, an R9 rating, and more oversight. A proposal gives you protection without these consequences.

Myth 6: “I can’t afford a consumer proposal.”

A proposal is often the most affordable debt solution available. Costs stay low because:

  • there are no upfront fees
  • trustee fees are included in your payment
  • no interest is ever charged
  • your payment never increases

Most people pay between $150 and $350 per month. The trustee designs the payment around your real budget, and the amount is based on what you can comfortably afford.

Myth 7: “I’ll be stuck in the proposal for years.”

A proposal usually lasts three to five years, but you can pay it off early with no penalties.

Many people finish ahead of schedule because they:

  • receive a tax refund
  • experience an income increase
  • get help from family
  • want to rebuild credit faster

Early repayment shortens the timeline and speeds up your recovery.

Myth 8: “Filing a proposal will affect my job.”

Consumer proposals are private.

Employers are not notified unless a wage garnishment must be stopped, and even then they only see that the garnishment has ended.

Most careers are completely unaffected, including government positions, licensed industries, financial services, and jobs requiring bonding. Bankruptcy may affect certain roles, but a proposal usually does not.

Myth 9: “Everyone will find out I filed.”

A consumer proposal is not public the way bankruptcy can be.

Only you, the trustee, and your creditors are aware of it. It is not published in newspapers or public registries. Your privacy is fully protected.

All unsecured debts, credit cards and unsecured loans can be applied to a consumer proposal, getting you completely debt free in 5 years or less!

Consumer Proposal Calculator


Worth Doing a Consumer Proposal

This consumer proposal calculator shows an approximate of how much you could save.

Let’s Get Started Today!

Insolvency Trustee Kelly Dey for Consumer Proposals

If you’re feeling overwhelmed by debt and not sure where to start, the best thing you can do is talk to someone who understands.

Call now and speak directly with me — Kelly Dey — for clear, honest advice that’s tailored to your situation. There’s no pressure and no judgment. We’ll look at your options together and create a plan that helps you breathe again. Getting started is easier than you think, and one simple conversation can put you back in control of your money and your life.

Let’s take that first step today, call 905-721-7506.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Are consumer proposals really private, or will people find out?

A. Consumer proposals are far more private than most people expect. Only you, your trustee, and your creditors are involved. The proposal isn’t published online, isn’t sent to friends or family, and doesn’t appear in newspapers. The only time your employer might see anything is if you already have a wage garnishment, and in that case, all they receive is a notice that the garnishment has ended — not the details behind it. For most people, the proposal stays completely confidential.

Q. Do creditors ever reject consumer proposals?

A. It’s rare for a proposal to be fully rejected. Trustees design proposals based on what creditors usually approve, so the offer is already aligned with industry expectations. Creditors tend to say yes because a proposal usually pays them more than a bankruptcy would. Even if they ask for changes, these adjustments are often small — such as a slightly higher monthly amount or a longer repayment term — and most people agree because the payment is still far below the original debt.

Q. Will a consumer proposal ruin my credit for years?

A. No. Your credit is affected at first, but the damage is temporary and much less than most people fear. Scores often begin to rise within a few months because your debt drops sharply, interest stops, and your payments become predictable. People who rebuild actively — using tools like secured credit cards, on-time bill payments, and low balances — often see meaningful increases long before the proposal is completed. In many cases, credit is stronger during the proposal than it was before filing.

Q. Is a consumer proposal the same as bankruptcy?

A. Not at all. They’re completely different processes. A proposal lets you keep your assets, gives you predictable payments, and reduces your debt by about 70%. Bankruptcy may require you to surrender assets, increases payments when your income rises, and places the strongest credit rating (R9) on your file. A proposal is more flexible, less intrusive, and easier to manage for anyone with steady income.

Q. Can a consumer proposal be paid off early?

A. Yes. You can pay off your proposal at any time with zero penalties.

Many people finish early because they receive a tax refund, get a raise, or want to rebuild credit faster. Early repayment shortens the R7 reporting period and starts your long-term credit recovery sooner. Paying it off early is one of the biggest advantages over other debt programs that lock you into fixed lengths.

Credit Score After a Consumer Proposal


Consumer Proposal Reviews - Credit Score After a Consumer Proposal

Kevin T.

3 days ago

★★★★★ I avoided calling for years because I believed all the myths. I thought I’d lose my home and that everyone would find out. None of it was true. The proposal cut my debt down by almost 70% and I kept everything. I wish I had done this sooner.

Alyssa D.

1 week ago

★★★★★ I always heard that a consumer proposal destroys your credit, but my score started improving within a few months. They explained every myth clearly and made the process simple. The truth was nothing like the scary stories I read online.

Gloria M.

2 weeks ago

★★★★★ I thought creditors would reject the proposal, but they accepted it right away. I learned that most of what I believed was wrong. The monthly payment was fair, interest stopped instantly, and I finally felt in control again.

Peter L.

3 weeks ago

★★★★★ I assumed a proposal was basically the same as bankruptcy, but it’s completely different. I didn’t lose anything, my income didn’t change the payment, and my debt dropped by thousands. They cleared up every myth I had.

Sandra R.

1 month ago

★★★★★ I believed a proposal would affect my job and that it would be public. Both were myths. Everything stayed private, and my employer only saw that the garnishment stopped. The whole process was easier and more respectful than I imagined.


Credit Score After a Consumer Proposal | How a Consumer Proposal Provides Debt Relief

Rise Above Your Debt!

Send an Email

Send Us an Email

Consumer Proposal Advantages - Logos

Consumer Proposals with YanchDey and Associates

Call 905-721-7506